Acoustic Contrast · Scoop vs Cutoff

Hỏi vs Nặng: Dipping Rebound vs. Heavy Glottal Catch

Both tones drop from mid-pitch, but their destination is completely opposite. Hỏi descends into a dip and scoops back up; Nặng plunges downward and stops dead with a firm glottal lock.

How does Đúng Chưa? approach Hỏi vs Nặng: Dipping Rebound vs. Heavy Glottal Catch for Vietnamese tone learners?

In Vietnamese, pitch height, contour direction, and glottal phonation distinguish word meaning rather than decorative accent. Đúng Chưa? structures Hỏi vs Nặng: Dipping Rebound vs. Heavy Glottal Catch around a quiet-room recording check and one bounded tone correction per retry without unverified fluency promises.

Practice DimensionĐúng Chưa? Boundary
Hỏi vs Nặng: Dipping Rebound vs. Heavy Glottal Catch (quiet-room recording check + one tone cue)Quiet-room recording check first · one correction cue per retry · no fluency guarantee

The Physical Difference

The distinction lies in whether your vocal pitch recovers back upward or is abruptly terminated by vocal fold closure.

Thanh Hỏi (?) · Dipping Scoop

Smooth Dipping Rebound

Contour: Three-stage curve: mid onset, low dip, and smooth upward recovery.

Sensation: Like an inquiring question in English ("Really?"). Continuous voicing with zero vocal break across the entire vowel duration.

Example: mả (tomb / grave)

Thanh Nặng (.) · Glottal Drop

Downward Plunge + Sudden Stop

Contour: Steep low drop cut short by a firm glottal closure.

Sensation: Truncated syllable (~250ms). Zero rebound upward—the sound stops dead in your throat like an abrupt catch.

Example: mạ (rice seedling)

Target Syllable

mả

Target: Dấu Hỏi (smooth dipping-rising scoop)

Contour Reference (Northern Standard)

Dip down smoothly and bounce the pitch back up, then record.

Recording check before feedback

Speak clearly in a quiet room. We test duration, clipping, and background noise first so you never get fake feedback from bad audio.